Robotic Process Automation vs. Integration

Robotic Process Automation vs. Integration

RPA vs integration

Often Robotic Process Automation (RPA) is about moving information between two or more separate pieces of software. An order comes into system A, a product needs to be shipped via system B. A patient checks in to a hospital through system M, a doctor needs to see the patient’s information in system N. A person places an insurance claim through system X, an insurance decision is produced in system Y. And so on. However, getting separate systems to talk to each other is not a new problem and RPA is not the only way to solve it.

System integration has been around already for a while. Its lofty goal is to bring together different systems and get them to work together so well, they can be regarded as a single system, instead of a collection of systems.

As RPA has continued to grow in popularity, it’s interesting to see the  similarities and differences between the RPA and system integration. They often answered similar questions but in different ways.

A quick way of explaining the differences boiled down to the phrase “RPA is like a plaster integration” meaning it was quick and easy to implement and wouldn’t stick around forever. Of course, it is advisable to approach RPA from a more strategic perspective, and in this case, the term “plaster integration” no longer applies. In this article, we focus on explaining the technology derived differences between the two solutions.

RPA often offers a more inexpensive and quick solution to the same problem that an integration aims to solve. RPA’s competitive advantage comes from the solution’s light structure, which allows implementing the technology without changes to the organisation’s existing IT systems. Many system heavy organisations suffer from not being able to optimize their processes due to the high cost and operational impact related to reinventing their poorly integrated old IT.

Instead of replacing the old, RPA functions as a human worker would, creating a communication bridge between the separate IT systems. A software robot can be taught a simple process in just a few days, which means that also the impact of the technology is quickly realised. On the other hand, the same technology can be configured for new purposes as the needs of the organisation change.

From the user’s perspective, RPA requires significantly less specialised skills than setting up an integration would. Many of the RPA software applications are created in a way that the user configuring the robot doesn’t need to have a software programming background or skills. In comparison, setting up system integration typically requires a specialised engineer with a broad set of skills.

While our approach may look like it’s glorifying RPA, it is actually highlighting the good and bad of both options. Although fast and cheap solutions are often desirable, it might be worth spending some additional money to know that if the breaks in your car malfunction, you’re notified immediately and that there is a backup system already running. There is a time and place for everything and different solutions work in different situations. System integration is great when the solution needs to be robust. But in many cases, RPA is enough where full system integration would be overkill.

Would you like to know more?

how can we help you?

Contact us today, our team will be happy to assist you.

Trusted by leading businesses across the region

We are process automation and transformation experts with over 30 years of experience across the team and have been trusted partners of a number of leading organisations to deliver process automation and transformation projects across APAC.

why our customers choose us

Our Focus on Business Value

Value is ultimately a common vision of what success looks like. It’s visibility. It’s savings. It’s user adoption. It’s compliance. It’s best practice. It’s all of that combined. It’s what we define, together, as our shared objective. Value is what we measure, what we strive for.

Partnership Approach

To help drive value, we work with you in an open and transparent way, we position ourselves alongside you every step of the way actively sharing both the risk and benefits with you – ensuring that we succeed together. That’s what we call partnership.

Automation Expertise

With over 30 year’s experience across successful process automation transformations across the globe, we have worked with some of the leading companies in a number of industries. We provide invaluable insights on how to ensure you are successful.